Metz's Quest for the Holy Grail

Tartaglia, James

Abstract

This paper is a critique of the new paradigm in analytic philosophy for investigating the meaning of life, focusing on Meaning in Life as the definitive example. Metz relies upon intuition, and reflection upon recent analytic literature, to guide him to his ‘fundamentality theory’. He calls this a theory of ‘the meaning of life’, saying it may be ‘the holy grail’. I argue that Metz’s project is not addressed to the meaning of life, but a distinct issue about social meaning; and that by neglecting and sidelining alternative approaches, his results are rendered provisional. I then argue that there are a number of equally legitimate senses of a ‘socially meaningful life’; that Metz’s exclusive and unjustified focus on only one radically diminishes the scope of his project; and that what remains is undermined by cultural specificity. Finally, I argue that the Kripkean semantics Metz adopts runs counter to his interests.

Citation

Tartaglia, J. (2015). Metz's Quest for the Holy Grail

• Publication Date: Sep 30, 2015
• Journal: Journal of the Philosophy of Life
• Print ISSN: 2185-4505
• Pages: 90-111
• Publisher URL: http://www.philosophyoflife.org/2015si06.html